Can’t replace “From Email”

Hi,

I love this smtp plugin! It’s really easy to use. I have one quandary concerning the ability to replace the “From Email”.

So I’m using example1@email.com to connect the SMTP. It’s an Outlook email if that helps. However, I’d like the notification emails the submitters receive to have a “from email” of an email group, emailgroup@email.com that we created in Outlook. Unfortunately the test emails, while they work, they come back with example1@email.com as the “From Field”.

Please see this screenshot for reference. I used the dummy emails as an example instead of the real ones. https://snag.gy/0TPe6I.jpg

Any advice on what I’m doing wrong is greatly appreciated!
Thanks!
R